How Climate Change Concern Can Motivate People To Be Interested In Your Offering

Climate change is stimulating unmet emotional desires within consumer society. In this study, a simple factual description of a new microgeneration product was presented to respondents - and the best predictor of enthusiasm for the product was whether the individual was very concerned about climate change, or not. As cleantech companies gear up for mass-market roll-out of their low-carbon products, we should expect those most concerned about climate change to be driving early adoption.

Cleantech companies might be forgiven for thinking that they need to concentrate on the performance and price of their products when marketing to consumers rather than placing much emphasis on their ‘low-carbon appeal’. Do people really get excited about the environmental performance of a gas boiler, or of installing low-energy light bulbs? After all, a recent survey by the department of transport in the UK[1] seems to suggest that climate change is low down the list of the public’s priorities. And in the US, the Pew Centre[2] recently concluded that “dealing with global warming ranks at the bottom of the public’s list of priorities.”

But by taking a consumer viewpoint, it is possible to conceptualise the low-carbon marketing environment in a rather different way.

The research data we have seen, including our own Environmental Choices^TM survey, indicates that the public is divided about climate change. In this context, it is entirely misleading to think of the public as a single entity that is ‘modestly concerned about climate change’. In short, some people are extremely concerned about climate change, and others, not at all.

Taking a metaphor from sport, our Environmental Choices^TM data also shows that 37% of English people are passionate about football, 30% are passionate about gardening, and 20% are passionate about rugby. If you think this means that English people are enthusiastic about football and gardening but are only modestly interested in rugby, you ought to get out more and buy tickets to a Six Nations international at Twickenham. Instead, we should be considering climate change, like rugby, as being a relatively minor ‘brand’. While minor brands typically suffer the double jeopardy of both smaller numbers of users who are less exclusively loyal, they can still create valuable franchises, and evoke powerful emotions among their followers.

And emotional connection is essential. Information and good economic arguments about your cleantech product is not enough. Consumers will have to want it and feel good about buying it. As a 2008 study about UK microgeneration stated: “Consumer behaviour towards buying energy efficient or ‘green’ products is found to derive from a mixture of so-called ‘rational’ factors – including economic analysis – and from emotional, societal and cultural factors. Consumer uptake has been slow even for rapid payback investments such as low energy light bulbs and [home] insulation.”[3]

But is it possible to put a value on the lowcarbon enthusiasm that certain people feel for low-carbon products? After all, people are not very good at accurately assigning their motivations for doing things.

The issue underlying this need is to measure ‘causality’ – how to measure the importance of various factors in getting people to act in a certain way. Somewhat akin to medical randomised trials, one approach is to separate people into those who are ‘concerned about climate change’ from those who are ‘unconcerned about climate change’ to see if there is a difference in the test outcome. This is what we did with our Environmental Choices study, using a statistical technique called CHAID.

As part of the study we tested consumer reactions to a simple, factual description of a prototype microgeneration product. The product profile had no brand positioning, no mention of the manufacturer, and did not refer to climate change or carbon emissions. The dependent variable were Enthusiasts for the product or not, defined as those who found the microgeneration product both ‘very appealing’ and who indicated they would be ‘very likely to install one’. The analysis was conducted among a nationally representative sample of 626 English people who fitted appropriate screening criteria.

For the predictor variables, we included a range of demographic variables (age/sex, region, number in household, income, political allegiance), as well as a three-way segmentation about people’s attitudes towards climate change. Climate Citizens (33% of this sample) are the people most concerned about climate change, and Sceptics/Uninvolved (27%) the least. Those who were mildly concerned about climate change we termed Mild Greens (40%).

The CHAID analysis showed that the best predictor for being an Enthusiast was whether someone was concerned about climate change or not. Of Climate Citizens, 25% were Enthusiasts compared with 13% of everyone else. This analysis provides evidence that ‘concern about climate change’ is a valuable motivator for this particular low-carbon product. It is also part of general findings from the Environmental Choices study that Climate Citizens are particularly likely to have interests and behaviours that are more ‘low-carbon’. As cleantech companies gear up for mass-market roll-out of their lowcarbon products, we should expect that Climate Citizens (representing a third of the population) to be driving early adoption.

1. http://www.dft.gov.uk/pgr/statistics/datatablespublications/trsnstatsatt/climatechgejan2010report
2. http://people-press.org/report/584/policy-priorities-2010
3. Page 26 (pdf) http://www.berr.gov.uk/files/file46003.pdf

This article was originally published in the April 2010 Sustainable Business.

This content was provided by Haddock Research & Branding, Inc. Visit their website at haddock-research.com. 

For your low-carbon product, do you really want to charge people extra for ‘being green’?

by Peter Winters, President, Haddock Research & Branding

There is sometimes a sense that green products should be charged at a price premium. But how often is this the right approach? Instead consider, for your green product, whether it can be positioned as being both greener and better value than competitors. Also, think what could be done to enhance each customer’s post-purchase satisfaction. Read Article »

Businesses must think about the unmet needs of their customers

by Peter Winters, President, Haddock Research & Branding

When governmental bodies try and get people to reduce their environmental impact, they sometimes talk about an ‘attitude-behaviour gap’. Instead, why not consider it as an ‘unmet need’, where consumers ‘low-carbon desires’ are not met by current ‘high-carbon behaviour’. This should move some of the responsibility away from ‘the consumer’, and onto businesses to think creatively about providing compelling low-carbon products and services. Read Article »

Anticipate resistance to your low-carbon initiative from ‘critical older men’

by Peter Winters, President, Haddock Research & Branding

Internationally, those who oppose government support for green initiatives tend to be older men. The similarity of this pattern between countries suggests that this goes beyond a national, cultural phenomenon – and one hypothesis is that it is to do with the more anti-social values of older men. For cleantech businesses, it is important to understand this demographic since investment risk in cleantech is so closely tied to the political risk of whether specific government green policies get implemented. Read Article »

Telepresence companies that employ ‘green positioning’ must do their market testing

by Peter Winters, President, Haddock Research & Branding

Some element of green positioning is ubiquitous for telepresence companies, and research shows that this is a real benefit for those business flyers who are very concerned about climate change. In the US, the 30% of business flyers who are Climate Citizens already tend to fly less, and tend to be more interested in telepresence. Yet, telepresence companies also need to consider how to communicate with those less concerned about climate change, how to make their services meet specific business needs, and how to differentiate themselves from their competitors. Read Article »

Monitor the discussion points – and take account of them in your media plans

by Peter Winters, President, Haddock Research & Branding

The role of market research is all about providing consumer perspectives to businesses in useful and reliable ways, since the view from the boardroom is almost inevitably different from that of their customers. What may seem consistent and reasonable to Al Gore, may not appear so to some of the public. For companies promoting low-carbon products, the key issue is to take a holistic view of how different types of people will view your communication messages. As a valuable addition to existing strategies, companies should monitor social media forums and take account of discussion points within their media plans. Read Article »

5 Top Tips For Low Carbon Marketing

by Peter Winters, President, Haddock Research & Branding

Challenge your assumptions on how to market your low carbon product. 5 top tips based on international primary research data. 28-minute presentation originally delivered to the SustainabilityLive! conference in Birmingham, England on April 21, 2010. Includes introduction about how an Icelandic volcano disrupted our plans, and how we came to use Brainshark. Read Article »

When distance is dead, it pays to consider global patterns first

by Peter Winters, President, Haddock Research & Branding

Whilst the communications technologies of 150 years ago helped establish many modern nation states, current technologies are undermining their relevance to business and social affairs. For market intelligence to be useful to business in a world where ‘distance is dead’, it should avoid making single national characterizations, consider global patterns before looking at regional variations, and adopt a detective/problem-solving approach. Read Article »

When it comes to risk, businesses must be more open with their customers

by Peter Winters, President, Haddock Research & Branding

The notion of ‘managing risk’ is a powerful framework for decision-making. What really differentiates how actively people are engaged with climate change is not their awareness or belief in it, but their attitudes towards how the risks should be tackled. Businesses, and governments, are being encouraged to take account of climate change risk. Maplecroft provides global non-financial risks information, and their analysis indicates that companies which are successful in implementing climate change innovations, tend to have better financial performance. Alex Bogusky argues that companies can better manage reputational risk by being more transparent with their customers. Read Article »