Case Study:
Conjoint Analysis: Product Line Strategy
by Sawtooth Technologies Consulting Group
In this case study Sawtooth Technologies conducted research into consumer preferences regarding mortgage product lines, modeled preferences for client and competitive products, and recommended an unexpected product strategy.
Situation
A major U.S. bank faced declining growth and increased competition in its residential mortgage business. The challenge was to determine product strategies to return the bank to its position of strength.
Research Steps
- Created a computer-based interview using conjoint analysis to allow consumers to express their trade-offs between attributes such as interest rates, type and name of institution, service offered, and other features.
- Calculated utilities that represented the decision-making weightings for each interviewee.
- Built a model of the market, featuring both a demand side (utility values) and supply side (available products).
-
Predicted the likely appeal of the bank’s product line as it was currently configured and tested a variety of scenarios:
- Added, changed and deleted items from the product line and compared the resulting outcomes
- Predicted competitive responses to the bank’s actions and modeled these actions, comparing outcomes under varying competitive situations
Research Results
The initial expectation—the client’s and ours—was that we would propose changes to the existing set of over a dozen products, but we were all surprised to see that the client’s share held up as products were removed from their line. We recommended a streamlined set of mortgages, cutting the product line in half, that the model predicted would strengthen the client’s market position.
Outcome
- Operational costs decreased because there was a smaller set of products to support.
- Marketing and advertising messages became significantly clearer with a smaller “grid” of products to promote.
- The mortgage market share increased dramatically after rollout of the new product line.
This content was provided by Sawtooth Technologies. Visit their website at www.sawtooth.com.
Other content shared by Sawtooth Technologies Consulting Group
Conjoint Analysis: New Product Selection
by Sawtooth Technologies Consulting Group
In this case study Sawtooth Technologies researched a variety of new products to determine which were most likely to succeed and which matched the client’s image/positioning in the financial market. Read Article »
Conjoint Analysis: B2B Customer Service Strategy
by Sawtooth Technologies Consulting Group
In this case study Sawtooth Technologies researched the values for service attributes in the channel (brokers, agents and distributors) and with end-customers.
Read Article »
Conjoint Analysis: Product Portfolio Optimization
by Sawtooth Technologies Consulting Group
In this case study Sawtooth Technologies conducted research into consumer preferences regarding various features and pricing of online classified ads. The objective was to develop an “optimal” product line that would increase sales volume. Read Article »
Conjoint Analysis: Staff Training
by Sawtooth Technologies Consulting Group
This report describes the process of teaching a client proper execution of a conjoint study to enable them to conduct their own studies in the future. Sawtooth Technologies trained the client's staff on multiple teaching points and illuminated distinct market segments for the client to focus on. Read Article »
Understanding Conjoint in 15 Minutes
by Joseph Curry, President, Sawtooth Technologies Consulting Group
This white paper arms you with the basics of conjoint analysis using a simple example. Read Article »
Finding the Sweet Spot of Competitive Positioning
by Sawtooth Technologies Consulting Group
The sweet spot of competitive positioning ensures your brand is relevant to the target audience and differentiated from the competition. This article from Sawtooth Technologies pinpoints ways to position your brand, particularly in the business-to-business market. Read Article »
Knowing when the Price is Right
by Sawtooth Technologies Consulting Group
Research on pricing products and services, obviously popular, can bring successful results through several different research methodologies: find the right one for you. Read Article »
MaxDiff – maximum power to act on market preferences
by Sawtooth Technologies Consulting Group
Determining preferences in product features or benefits, marketing slogans, logos, service options, or even restaurant names, allows for trial and error without the error. Read Article »
Predicting Choice with Conjoint Analysis and Discrete Choice
by Sawtooth Technologies Consulting Group
Conjoint Analysis and Discrete Choice are popular techniques because they let marketers predict choice behavior. Follow this detailed example from Sawtooth Technologies. Read Article »
Segmenting for Success
by Sawtooth Technologies Consulting Group
Segmenting for success in both consumer and B2B markets means going beyond traditional segmenting variables, such as demographics or company type, and focusing on needs, attitudes and lifestyle. In this article Sawtooth Technologies highlights the benefits, approach, and uses of segmenting a market in such a way. Read Article »
Discrete Choice Analysis Makes Comparing Apples to Oranges Possible
by Sawtooth Technologies Consulting Group
Discrete choice lets you understand how your market makes relevant apples to oranges comparisons. Sawtooth Technologies provides an example question for this type of scenario. Read Article »
Predicting Revenue from Conjoint Results
by Sawtooth Technologies Consulting Group
Conjoint analysis is a powerful tool for predicting market reaction to changes in existing products or services or completely new products. But how well do conjoint model results translate into real world results? And can you predict revenue from conjoint results? Read Article »
Aligning Your Line: Using Conjoint to Manage Product Lines
by Sawtooth Technologies Consulting Group
It is common to think about using conjoint / discrete choice to configure products and test pricing, but it also extremely useful for finding opportunities to shrink product lines, testing whether additional products cannibalize or add to preference, and uncovering segments and aligning products with their preferences. Read Article »
MaxDiff: A New Way to Prioritize Benefit Statements
by Sawtooth Technologies Consulting Group
MaxDiff is a great methodology for prioritizing benefit statements. You’ll learn which statements resonate most with your market in this article. Read Article »
Conjoint/Discrete Choice Model Output: What’s the Share About?
by Sawtooth Technologies Consulting Group
When business decision-makers look at conjoint and discrete choice model output, how should the share results be interpreted and used? In this post, we share our thoughts about preference share and market share, based on decades of practical experience. Read Article »
Asking Discrete Choice Questions When the Answer is, “It Depends”
by Sawtooth Technologies Consulting Group
Discrete choice questions are typically straightforward – “Which product do you prefer?” However, in some situations, the respondent may be thinking, “It depends.” This article describes these situations and some possible solutions. Read Article »
Using Discrete Choice and MaxDiff to Spend HR Dollars Wisely
by Sawtooth Technologies Consulting Group
Especially in times of shrinking budgets, it is critically important to allocate benefits dollars wisely. Human Resources departments have the opportunity to use customer-focused approaches to maximize ROI. Techniques such as Discrete Choice Analysis and MaxDiff can help companies maximize employee satisfaction for each dollar spent. Read Article »
Why I Still Love Conjoint
by Sawtooth Technologies Consulting Group
Conjoint analysis, also referred to as discrete choice, has been in use for decades. What has led to its popularity? Why does it keep researchers, academicians, and research end-users engaged? In short, why do we still love conjoint? Read Article »
