On-Demand Insights: H&M Wins Hearts and Minds with Plus-Size Swimwear Model

H&M followed words with actions by hiring a size 12 model as the star of this summer’s swimsuit ad campaign. Here at GutCheck, we wanted to dive a level deeper than the current media coverage to understand the brass tacks insights underneath the buzz.

What a positioning contrast we’ve recently witnessed between A&F and H&M.  On the one hand, Abercrombie & Fitch CEO essentially reaffirmed that it only “want[s] to market to cool, good-looking people”. On the other hand, Hennes & Maurit CEO Karl-Johan Persson, told Metro World News recently that, “Some of our models have been too skinny. That’s not OK.”
 
H&M followed words with actions by hiring a 5’10’’ size 12 model as the star of this summer’s swimsuit ad campaign. And anecdotally speaking, the ads featuring plus-size model Jennie Runk have generated some positive buzz according to Time and AdWeek.
 
Here at GutCheck, we wanted to dive a level deeper than the current media coverage to understand the brass tacks insights underneath the buzz. Specifically, we wanted to answer these questions:
  • Do women actually prefer the ad with the size 12 model to one with a size 0 model?
  • And if so, to what degree and why?
 
So, we fired up an Instant Research Community (IRC) this week to answer these questions. Within an hour of kick-off this past Wed morning, we had our 40 female recruits raring to go. Twenty-four hours later, our ladies completed the guided discussion, collaborated heartily with one another, and gave us some fantastic insights. First and foremost: H&M is hitting it out of the park with this ad campaign. Take a look at the infographic our research team at Gutcheck put together yesterday once the community ended.
 
The key takeway: 76% preferred the ad with the size 12 model while 14% preferred the size 0 model. The media buzz would lead you to believe that the former would win; the key insight, however, is that it won by over 5x! And the reasons were both emotional (“A beautiful ad that I feel would relate to a lot of women.”) and rational (“It’s hard to picture myself in some of the clothing since I am not as small as the model.”).
 
I started with a contrast, so I guess it’s only fitting that I end with one:
  • A&F Q1 sales: -9% worldwide and -17% in the US (source: Abercrombie & Fitch)
  • H&M Q1 sales: +6% worldwide (source: H&M) 
 
Given H&M’s recent marketing and financial successes, I wonder if A&F is reconsidering its market focus. I sure would be.
 
 
This content was provided by GutCheck. Visit their website at gutcheckit.com.

Sign Up for
Updates

Get content that matters, written by top insights industry experts, delivered right to your inbox.

67k+ subscribers