January 19, 2011

Screening & Incentivizing for Crowdsourcing Ideation? “No” & “No”!

By Kevin Lonnie, CEO of KL Communications “The most imaginative influences often come from the most unlikely sources.” The above is a quote from a recent TED Conference on nurturing…

By Kevin Lonnie, CEO of KL Communications

“The most imaginative influences often come from the most unlikely sources.”

The above is a quote from a recent TED Conference on nurturing the creative process.

http://www.ted.com/talks/elizabeth_gilbert_on_genius.html

This theorem appears to be in conflict with screening tactics to preselect a potential Crowdsourcing panel.  Pre-testing makes sense if you’re looking to vet Jeopardy contestants, but are we being presumptuous on who is capable of creative input?

I’m focusing specifically on MR applications for Crowdsourcing.  My interest is in bringing the power of the crowd to idea generation and more specifically, insights that can be monetized for a demonstrative ROI.   That is why I prefer the idea of an open casting call, with availability to anyone with a passion for the category.

If we accept that all of us are capable of occasional flashes of brilliance, then what is to be gained by adding some artificially derived litmus test to our invitation?

And while we’re at it, let’s take our rules of engagement one step further.  Rather than paying someone to join our “Verified Creative for Crowdsourcing Your Next Idea” panel, how about charging admission to our panel?

Let’s assign an agreed upon prize to the winner and perhaps some secondary prizes to the most helpful contributors, but charge everyone a token amount to join our challenge.  This would weed out any and all mercenaries (Can you see a typical professional respondent spitting out his coffee when he reads we want to charge him for joining!)

All money collected from the crowd would be assigned to our winners, along with any guaranteed money.  In this way, we can gain viral buzz (Did you hear about this cool contest?  The winner’s share is now up to $$$!).  As word spreads organically, we will attract more and more participants all interested in gaining their share of our progressive payout.

In summary then, I would argue for:

1. An open casting call for every Crowdsourcing challenge

  • No supposition of talent, nor reliance on a pre-selected “Creatives” Panel

2. A token entry fee for participation (e.g. $2.99, about the same cost as a mobile app)

3. Effective & widespread promotion of our Crowdsourced challenge

  • Viral buzz is critical for the challenge to take on a life of its own.  As the saying goes, “Nothing attracts a crowd, like a crowd.”

 

market research innovationrespondent engagement

Comments

Comments are moderated to ensure respect towards the author and to prevent spam or self-promotion. Your comment may be edited, rejected, or approved based on these criteria. By commenting, you accept these terms and take responsibility for your contributions.

Disclaimer

The views, opinions, data, and methodologies expressed above are those of the contributor(s) and do not necessarily reflect or represent the official policies, positions, or beliefs of Greenbook.

More from Kevin Lonnie

Breaking Free From The Jaws of Mediocrity
GRIT

Breaking Free From The Jaws of Mediocrity

The Buyer’s Perspective: Scholar Walter J. Ong once published a brilliant essay about the challenges of effective communication titled, The writer’s a...

3 Core Requirements for Agile Market Research in 2020

3 Core Requirements for Agile Market Research in 2020

Learn the key requirements for implementing Agile Market Research.

4 Agile Market Research Techniques to Expect in 2018

4 Agile Market Research Techniques to Expect in 2018

See what market research techniques are expected to make news in 2018.

Idea Meritocracy & Its Implications for Market Research
Research Technology (ResTech)

Idea Meritocracy & Its Implications for Market Research

Find out how AI and automation can help solve the big “Why” questions for with “Idea Meritocracy” and algorithmic decision making.

Sign Up for
Updates

Get content that matters, written by top insights industry experts, delivered right to your inbox.

67k+ subscribers